Black Coaches Association - A planned positive vision of the future.

Reese leads the New York Giants to a Super Bowl victory

A Giant Upset Is Exciting, But Hard To Repeat

Feb. 4, 2008

On January 7, 2007, Jerry Reese sat in the press box at Philadelphia's Lincoln Financial Field and watched the Giants lose on a field goal as time expired in a wild-card playoff game against the Eagles. Despite the outcome, Reese, then the Giants' director of player personnel, was encouraged.

 

 

New York had gone 8-8 during the regular season. It had a slew of players on injured reserve, including defensive end Michael Strahan, wide receiver Amani Toomer, defensive end Justin Tuck and cornerback Corey Webster. Yet the team had lost by only three points to the NFC East champs.

 

Reese believed the Giants could have won that game. If we can get our players back, he thought to himself, we're not that far away.

 

Thirteen months later, things have changed.

 

Reese is now the Giants' general manager; the first African American G.M. of a Super Bowl team, he was named to his new post, appropriately, on Martin Luther King Day. He replaced Ernie Accorsi, who retired. Those four players who were on I.R. did come back -- and they made vital contributions. Eli Manning has taken the giant step from a pedestrian quarterback during his first three seasons to a premier one this postseason.

 

And now the Giants are world champions.

 

On Sunday night in Glendale, Ariz., they shocked the New England Patriots, who were on the threshold of becoming the first 19-0 team in league history, the rest of the NFL and the world by scoring a 17-14 victory in Super Bowl 42 -- one of the biggest upsets in NFL history.

 

"Nobody gave us a chance the last four weeks," says Plaxico Burress, who caught the winning touchdown pass from Manning with 35 seconds left. "Now, everybody can jump on the bandwagon."

 

The Giants will take a few moments to embrace their improbable season and their new title. Then the organization must turn its attention to such important offseason matters as the NFL Scouting Combine, which opens February 20; the start of free agency, which will follow on February 29; and the draft in April.

 

If you think winning the Super Bowl is a huge challenge, returning to it the next year is a Herculean task. What the Giants do over the next several months will set the foundation for whether they'll be in the championship picture again in 2008.

 

But we'll get to that later. First, let's acknowledge their crowning achievement.

 

Although they came to Arizona propelled by dual jet engines of momentum -- three straight postseason victories and 10 consecutive road wins -- the NFC's fifth-seeded Giants were prohibitive underdogs. The 18-0 Patriots were favored by 12 points and trying to lay claim to their fourth Super Bowl title in seven years. But the Giants derailed New England's flawless aspirations with a near-perfect performance of their own.

 

The defense pressured Patriots quarterback Tom Brady, the NFL's MVP, into a state of claustrophobia with its constant pressure. Led by Tuck (two sacks), Strahan (one) and the occasional blitzing linebacker or defensive back, New York sacked Brady five times, knocked him down at least a dozen more and disrupted his rhythm most of the game.

 

Manning did a pretty good impression of his brother Peyton, who watched in admiration from a suite at University of Phoenix Stadium, by completing 19 of 34 passes for 255 yards and two touchdowns. Of the two quarterbacks, you would have thought Brady would have displayed the better poise. But Manning, playing in his first Super Bowl, was a cool customer.

 

The Patriots took a 14-10 lead with 2:42 remaining when Brady finished a 12-play, 80-yard scoring drive with a 6-yard pass to Randy Moss. Then Manning stepped into the spotlight and produced his finest moments as an NFL quarterback.

 

Starting at the New York 17, he orchestrated a brilliant retaliation. Standing in shotgun formation throughout the series, he completed five of nine passes for 77 yards. He scrambled for 5 yards on a first-down play, then completed a 32-yard pass to David Tyree two plays later. Then came the coup de grace.

 

Enter Manning's accomplice, Burress, who had been plagued by a sore ankle all season and a swollen knee that kept him out of practice most of the week before the game. Until then, Burress had caught only one pass for 14 yards. But he maintained a patient demeanor, hoping his big moment would come.

 

On first-and-10 from the New England 13, Burress lined up on the left, facing single coverage against cornerback Ellis Hobbs. While studying film during the week, Burress had noticed Hobbs tended to slow his feet near the goal line and often tried to jump slant routes. Burress came off the line fast, made a move like he was going to run a post, then turned outside.

 

The double move fooled Hobbs, who slipped. Burress stood all alone in the corner of the end zone as Manning's rainbow pass descended toward him. What was Burress thinking? "Just catch it," he says. "And make sure your feet are in bounds. When I caught it, it was like, 'Ahhhh.' "

 

With his game-winning catch, Burress removed some self-imposed pressure. Earlier in the week, he had opened his "big mouth" and predicted a 23-17 Giants victory. At the time, it was a foolish assertion that was not looked on kindly by Giants coach Tom Coughlin. But his words turned out to be prescient.

 

In the Giants locker room, backup cornerback Kevin Dockery carried a giant bottle of Dom Perignon, vintage 1999. Asked when he was going to pop the cork, he replied, "I don't know if it'll ever get opened."

 

Pat Hanlon, the team's vice president of communications, wore a preprinted blue T-shirt that marked the moment. On the back were the words: "You gotta hang No. 1 to be No. 1." It even had the teams' final records: Giants 14-6, Patriots 18-1. Talk about prescient.

 

Then there was Manning, who wore a grin as wide as the Hudson River. He posed for a picture with his proud papa, former NFL quarterback Archie Manning, and accepted congratulations from brothers Peyton and Cooper. He came to Arizona with the skeptics still doubting his credentials as an elite quarterback and returned to New York with the game's MVP trophy.

 

"You've got to tip your hat to everyone in here," Tuck said as he stood in front of his locker. "It was a collective deal. I know they have to have an MVP, but you could have given the MVP to everybody. The O-line did a great job, the running backs did a great job, our D-line was great, the secondary ... You could go on and on.

 

"This is a hell of a story. This is what legends are made of."


The question now is: What kind of sequel will the Giants write? With the exception of the Patriots, Super Bowl teams have been hard-pressed to return to the big game the following season. NFC teams, in particular, have suffered a Super Bowl hangover.

 

Of that conference's previous 10 Super Bowl representatives, only three had winning records and returned to the playoffs the next year: the 1998 Packers, the 2000 Rams and the 2006 Seahawks. Of the other seven teams, five went 7-9 the year after their Super Bowl, one went 6-10 and one went 5-11.

 

"That's why I kind of marvel at how New England has been able to maintain for the last seven years," says Reese. "The league is built so that everybody has a chance. For them to be on top for seven years, that's impressive."

 

Championship-caliber teams are built in the offseason. They also can be torn asunder during that time. But the Giants didn't exactly put their offseason on hold while they were making their postseason run. While their coaches concentrated on game plans and prepared the players for four extra games, their scouts and other personnel people started laying the groundwork for free agency and the draft.

 

"You can't just stop and relax because you're in the Super Bowl," Reese said last Thursday at the team's hotel in Chandler, Ariz. "We travel home Monday, and our predraft meetings start on Friday. So it never really ends. We're working harder than ever right now because we want the chance to be in this situation every year."

 

The NFL's essence is equalitarianism. Its guidelines aren't designed to reward excellence. As winners of the Super Bowl, the Giants will get the last pick in the first round of the draft. They'll have to shift into high gear to catch up to the other teams that have jump-starts on their offseasons. And, of course, they'll have many personnel decisions to make.

 

Among their free agents-to-be are linebacker Kawika Mitchell, safety Gibril Wilson and running back Derrick Ward. They probably will try to keep all three.

 

They need to upgrade their secondary. Rookie Aaron Ross and third-year pro Webster, who came on strong down the stretch after being benched early in the season, look like they could be solid cornerbacks for years. But Sam Madison and R.W. McQuarters are aging, and one, or both, likely will be gone. The team also could replace strong safety James Butler, who hasn't lived up to his reputation as a rangy ballhawk.

 

Rookie wide receiver Steve Smith, who came back after missing much of the regular season with a fractured scapula, is a guy who can come up with big catches in the middle of the field. That could mean Sinorice Moss, who has been a disappointment in his first two seasons, is expendable.

 

And the Giants might have to replace first-year defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo, who created the masterful game plan that held the Patriots to 14 points and 274 yards. The man the Giants call "Spags" has been courted by the Redskins as a candidate to replace retired coach Joe Gibbs.

 

If there is a downside to winning the Super Bowl, it's that players sometimes lose their drive to get back and focus on improving their own situations.

 

"Everybody says, 'We made it to the Super Bowl, so this is my year to ask for a new contract or go into free agency,' " says Seahawks general manager Tim Ruskell. "Everybody is trying to take advantage of what just happened."

 

Ruskell has experienced what Reese is about to go through. After making it to Super Bowl 40, where they lost to the Steelers, the Seahawks struggled during the succeeding months. They lost premier guard Steve Hutchinson to the Vikings, they neglected to give their players and coaches enough time off to recharge their batteries, and they suffered a slew of injuries early in the 2006 season -- perhaps a consequence of their condensed offseason. Quarterback Matt Hasselbeck (knee) missed four games, running back Shaun Alexander (broken foot) was sidelined for six games and ineffective for others, and, by the end of the season, 14 players were hurt or on injured reserve.

 

"We fought it all year," Ruskell says of the Super Bowl's aftereffect. "We really didn't feel like we were a team in terms of playing up to our ability until late in the year. And then in the end, we got hot."

 

The Seahawks won the NFC West and beat Dallas in a wild-card playoff game before losing to Chicago, in overtime, in the next round. But they were the exception to the recent trend in the NFC.

 

Asked what advice he has for the Giants, Ruskell says, "Work hard to maintain your core players. Don't lose sight of the fact you still have to recruit for free agency. You've got to give the players a break, even if it backs up your offseason program. You've got to give them some downtime, even though it'll come up on you quick and you'll say, 'We've got to do this and we have to do that.' Maybe you don't. Maybe you can cut back."

 

As Reese walked around the Giants' locker room Sunday night, shaking the hands of players and coaches, the next step in the team's evolution was in the back of his mind. "We're just going to enjoy the moment for right now," he said. "We'll get back to work in a couple days. The cycle never stops. We'll keep moving."

 

Reese and the Giants came a long way in just one year. Now the journey will really get challenging.

 
Dennis Dillon is a writer for Sporting News. E-mail him at ddillon@sportingnews.com.